22.3.16

Secret E-Scores Chart Consumers’ Buying Power (2)

AMERICANS are obsessed with their scores. Credit scores, G.P.A.’s, SAT’s, blood pressure and cholesterol levels — you name it.
So here’s a new score to obsess about: the e-score, an online calculation that is assuming an increasingly important, and controversial, role in e-commerce.
These digital scores, known broadly as consumer valuation or buying-power scores, measure our potential value as customers. What’s your e-score? You’ll probably never know. That’s because they are largely invisible to the public. But they are highly valuable to companies that want — or in some cases, don’t want — to have you as their customer.
Online consumer scores are calculated by a handful of start-ups, as well as a few financial services stalwarts, that specialize in the flourishing field of predictive consumer analytics. It is a Google-esque business, one fueled by almost unimaginable amounts of data and powered by complex computer algorithms. The result is a private, digital ranking of American society unlike anything that has come before.
It’s true that credit scores, based on personal credit reports, have been around for decades. And direct marketing companies have long ranked consumers by their socioeconomic status. But e-scores go further. They can take into account facts like occupation, salary and home value to spending on luxury goods or pet food, and do it all with algorithms that their creators say accurately predict spending.
A growing number of companies, including banks, credit and debit card providers, insurers and online educational institutions are using these scores to choose whom to woo on the Web. These scores can determine whether someone is pitched a platinum credit card or a plain one, a full-service cable plan or none at all. They can determine whether a customer is routed promptly to an attentive service agent or relegated to an overflow call center.
Federal regulators and consumer advocates worry that these scores could eventually put some consumers at a disadvantage, particularly those under financial stress. In effect, they say, the scores could create a new subprime class: people who are bypassed by companies online without even knowing it. Financial institutions, in particular, might avoid people with low scores, reducing those people’s access to home loans, credit cards and insurance.
It might seem strange that one innovator in this sphere has blossomed here in St. Cloud, a world away from the hothouse of Silicon Valley. It is called eBureau, and it develops eScores — its name for custom scoring algorithms — to predict whether someone is likely to become a customer or a money-loser. Gordy Meyer, the founder and chief executive, says his system needs less than a second to size up a consumer and to transmit his or her score to an eBureau client.
“It’s like gambling,” Mr. Meyer says. “It’s a game of odds, when to double down and when to pass.”
Every month, eBureau scores about 20 million American adults on behalf of clients like banks, payday lenders and insurers, looking to buy the names of prospective customers. An eBureau spinoff called TruSignal, also located here, scores about 110 million consumers monthly for advertisers seeking select audiences for online ads. Mr. Meyer says eBureau’s clients use the scores to answer basic business questions about their potential audience.
“Are they legitimate?” Mr. Meyer asks. “Are they worth pursuing? Are they worth spending money on?” The scores, he adds, are generated without using federally regulated consumer data and are not used to make credit decisions about consumers. (Using regulated credit data for marketing purposes could run afoul of federal law.)
Such assurances aside, consumer value scores have begun to trouble some federal regulators. One of their worries is that these scores, which have spread quietly through American business, measure individuals against one another, using yardsticks that are essentially secret. Another is that the scores could pigeonhole people, limit their financial choices and channel some into predatory loans, they say.
“The scoring is a tool to enable financial institutions to make decisions about financing based on unconventional methods,” says David Vladeck, the director of the bureau of consumer protection at the Federal Trade Commission. “We are troubled by these practices.”
Federal law governs the use of old-fashioned credit scores. Companies must have a legally permissible purpose before checking consumers’ credit reports and must alert them if they are denied credit or insurance based on information in those reports. But the law does not extend to the new valuation scores because they are derived from nontraditional data and promoted for marketing.
Ed Mierzwinski, consumer program director at the United States Public Interest Research Group in Washington, worries that federal laws haven’t kept pace with change in the digital age.
“There’s a nontransparent, opaque scoring system that collects information about you to generate a score — and what your score is results in the offers you get on the Internet,” he says. “In most cases, you don’t know who is collecting the information, you don’t know what predictions they have made about you, or the potential for being denied choice or paying too much.”
ON the ground floor of eBureau’s headquarters are the company’s prized assets: several hundred computer processors that analyze billions of details about consumers every month. EBureau has built a glass enclosure on a raised platform to showcase the machines. From the dimly lit viewing hall, tiny green and blue lights flicker behind glass.
Photo
Mr. Meyer at a LeadsCon conference. He says eBureau’s system needs less than a second to size up a consumer and transmit his or her eScore. CreditTina Fineberg for The New York Times
Like many facets of eBureau, the idea of putting the processors on a pedestal came from Mr. Meyer, 51, whose relaxed uniform of jeans and cotton shirts belies the methodological decider underneath.
Continue reading the main story

“Traditional ways to evaluate credit didn’t exist on half of them,” he recalls. “So Fingerhut had to come up with a way to decide who they mailed catalogs to and who they ultimately approved orders to.”
Back then, he says, Fingerhut evaluated creditworthiness based in part on how people filled out order forms. Those who used pens were seen as safer bets than those who used pencils. People who used a middle initial were considered better credit risks than those who didn’t. After an analysis by Mr. Meyer, he says, the company also began scoring first-time customers based on whether their phones were connected and their phone numbers legitimate. (Those whose phones did not work were considered at high risk of defaulting on payments.)
Using these different scoring techniques, Mr. Meyer says, Fingerhut could efficiently tailor its catalogs and offers to different customers; decide whether to approve or decline certain product orders; or choose which customer debts to collect on or write off.
“Without Fingerhut,” Mr. Meyer says, “I would never be in this business.”(Fingerhut is now an online and catalog retailer.)
In the 1990s, Mr. Meyer decided to use his expertise in spotting patterns of fraud to start RiskWise, an analytics enterprise of his own. After selling it, and two other companies, to LexisNexis in 2000 for about $89 million, he founded another start-up: a predictive analytics company that would become eBureau.
EVERY business needs customers. But how do you find them, and how do you know they will be good ones? In 2006, Mr. Meyer began to answer that question by carving a niche for himself in a nascent online industry called “lead generation.”
Lead generators are companies that set up consumer-friendly Web sites with the goal of funneling potential customers to businesses ranging from financial institutions to wedding photographers. It is a multibillion-dollar industry in the United States, says Jay Weintraub, chief executiveof LeadsCon, a conference for Web sites that specializes in online customer acquisition.
Lead-generation sites like Bankrate.com, for example, offer rate calculators and other tools that prompt people to fill out forms with their names and contact information. The sites then transmit those consumers’ information to mortgage brokers, credit card issuers, car insurers and the like, offering access to these prospective customers, or leads, in return for a finder’s fee. The price varies. Lead generators may charge $8 for an insurance prospect; $35 for a finance lead; or $75 for a mortgage prospect, Mr. Meyer says.
But, he says, some companies were buying more than 100,000 leads a month without being able to distinguish one from another. They couldn’t sort potentially profitable customers from window-shoppers and fakes.
“Are people who are filling out the forms telling the truth? Because Yogi Bear and Fred Flintstone don’t buy a lot of stuff,” Mr. Meyer says. “Companies needed to figure out whether these leads were quality or not.”
Big national and international brands, Mr. Meyer knew, already employed data analytics to rate consumers. To distinguish his firm, he developed eBureau to offer customized scoring systems to midsize companies.
Here’s how eScores work:
A client submits a data set containing names of tens of thousands of sales leads it has already bought, along with the names of leads who went on to become customers. EBureau then adds several thousand details — like age, income, occupation, property value, length of residence and retail history — from its databases to each customer profile. From those raw data points, the system extrapolates up to 50,000 additional variables per person. Then it scours all that data for the rare common factors among the existing customer base. The resulting algorithm scores prospective customers based on their resemblance to previous customers.
EScores might range from 0 to 99, with 99 indicating a consumer who is a likely return on investment and 0 indicating an unprofitable one. But in some industries, “knowing the bottom is more important than knowing the top,” Mr. Meyer says. In online education, for instance, scores help schools winnow prospective students who are not worth the investment of expensive course catalogs or attentive follow-up calls — like people who use fake names or adopt the identities of relatives.
“If we can find 25 percent who have zero chance of enrolling, we can say ‘don’t waste your money on them,’ ” he says.
EBureau charges clients 3 to 75 cents a score, depending on the industry and the volume of leads.
Such scores increase the accuracy and speed with which companies can identify potential customers, says Mr. Weintraub of the LeadsCon conference.
“Scores tell you ‘this person might actually qualify, so let’s focus on them,’ ” he says. “This way you are not focusing on people who really can’t qualify.”
MOST people never see their value scores. But some services openly discuss how their measurements work. A case study on the eBureau site, for example, describes how the company ranked prospective customers for a national prepaid debit card issuer, assigning each a score of 0 to 998. People who scored above 950 were considered likely to become highly profitable customers, generating revenue over six months of an estimated $213 per card. Those who scored less than 550 were predicted to be unprofitable clients, with estimated revenue of $74 or less. With e-Bureau’s system, the card issuer could identify and court the high scorers while avoiding low scorers.
TargusInfo, a subsidiary of Neustar that is an eBureau competitor, is even more explicit about how a multinational credit card issuer used its scores.
According to a case study on its site, TargusInfo instantly scores prospective customers who call the card company’s call centers, selecting the kind of card to offer even before an agent picks up the phone. The scores also alert agents to high-value prospects, people “who are more likely to apply, be approved, request supplemental cards or spend more in their first year,” the case study says. While high-value callers are immediately routed to dedicated agents, it says, “less-qualified callers no longer waste the valuable time of the card issuer’s dedicated agents and are routed to an outsourced overflow call center.”
Becky Burr, chief privacy officer of Neustar, sees TargusInfo’s scoring system as a modern incarnation of marketing services to help companies find and communicate with their audiences.
“They want to allocate their marketing money efficiently, and consumers want messages that are relevant,” she says. The scores, she adds, should be seen as predictions about groups of consumers, not judgments on individuals.
For companies, this kind of scoring clearly increases the speed and reduces the cost of acquiring customers. But consumers are paying a heavy price for that increased corporate efficiency, public interests advocates say.
The digital scores create a two-tiered system that invisibly prioritizes some online users for credit and insurance offers while denying the same opportunities to others, says Mr. Mierzwinski of the Public Interest Research Group. The decades-old federal law that protects consumers from unfair credit practices, he says, has not kept pace with online innovation.
The Fair Credit Reporting Act requires that consumer reporting agencies, the companies that compile credit data, show people their credit reports and allow them to correct errors. Companies that use the reports must notify consumers if they take adverse action based on information in those reports. But digital marketers, Mr. Mierzwinski says, are able to work around the rules by using alternative financial data to calculate consumer scores. In an article scheduled to be published next spring in the Suffolk University Law Review, Mr. Mierzwinski and a co-author argue that new digital techniques like scoring let sales agents rapidly convert online prospects to customers, blurring the line between marketing and actual credit offers.
“The relationship between marketing and making a distinct offer of credit to a consumer is becoming blurred given contemporary digital marketing practices,” Mr. Mierzwinski and his co-author, Jeffrey Chester of theCenter for Digital Democracy, write in the article. Federal regulators, they add, “should ensure consumers know whether and how they have been secretly scored or rated by the digital financial marketers, especially those labeled as less profitable or desirable.”
Mr. Meyer and other eBureau executives disagree, saying the concerns are misplaced.
EBureau, Mr. Meyer says, went to great lengths to build a system with both regulatory requirements and consumer privacy in mind. The company, he says, has put firewalls in place to separate databases containing federally regulated data, like credit or debt information used for purposes like risk management, from databases about consumers used to generate scores for marketing purposes.
He adds that eBureau’s clients use the scores only to narrow their field of prospective customers — not for the purposes of approving people for credit, loans or insurance. Moreover, he says, the company does not sell consumer data to others, nor does it retain the scores it transmits to clients.
“We are an evaluator,” Mr. Meyer says. “We are trying to stay away from being intrusive to the consumer.”
AT a LeadsCon conference in Midtown Manhattan last month, eBureau was among those making its sales pitch. Its exhibition booth depicted a multiethnic group of fictional consumers and their hypothetical scores.
Score boxes superimposed over a young African-American male read variously: “eScore: 811, high lifetime value potential” and “eScore: 524, underbanked, but safe credit risk.” Another caption floating over the crowd read: “eScore: 906, route to best call center agent NOW!”
It’s just another sign of the rise of what might be called the Scored Society. Google ranks our search results by our location and search history. Facebook scores us based on our online activities. Klout scores usby how many followers we have on Twitter, among other things.
And now e-scores rank our potential value to companies.
But the spread of consumer rankings raises deep questions of fairness, says Frank Pasquale, a professor at Seton Hall University School of Law, who is writing a book about scoring technologies. The scores may help companies, he says. But over time, they may send some consumers into a downward spiral, locking them into a world of digital disadvantage.
“I’m troubled by the idea that some people will essentially be seeing ads for subprime loans, vocational schools and payday loans,” Professor Pasquale says, “while others might be seeing ads for regular banks and colleges, and not know why.”

27.2.16

EL LOBBISME DES DE LA POLÍTICA

Grans noms vinguts de la política, a esquerra i a dreta, posen el seu poder d'influència al servei de les elèctriques 
10/01/16 02:00 - BARCELONA - JORDI GARRIGA RIU 
El viatge del càrrec amb responsabilitat a l'administració cap a un lloc en una de les grans empreses del sector elèctric s'ha convertit en un fet normalitzat en un sector que es resisteix a perdre el seu caràcter concessional. 

El polític que arriba d'un ministeri al consell d'administració d'una gran elèctrica duu una gran agenda d'influències i una capacitat de pressió, sobre l'executiu i el legislatiu, que no és menyspreable. De vegades, es tracta simplement de pagar serveis prestats. Un joc, el de portes giratòries, en què s'hi juga des de l'esquerra i des de la dreta. 

En el reguitzell de fitxatges enlluernadors d'Endesa, va destacar amb llum pròpia fins al 2014 tot un president, José María Aznar, que s'enduia per fer lobbisme uns 200.000 euros a l'any. En aquesta tasca hi vam veure, abans de ser ministre d'Economia, Luis de Guindos, i va anar de ben poc que el seu seient al consell l'ocupés Rodrigo Rato. El partit de la gavina també va tenir com a candidat tot un expresident d'aquesta elèctrica, Manuel Pizarro, l'home que es va encarregat de neutralitzar l'opa de Gas Natural sobre Fenosa. 

Però Endesa també ha tingut al seu consell personatges del cantó oposat en l'espectre polític, amb tota una ministra d'Economia, Elena Salgado, que tot just deixar l'alt càrrec va esdevenir vocal del consell d'administració de la filial xilena de l'elèctrica. També procedent del PSOE, i amb aura ministerial, és Joan Majó, antic titular d'Indústria i membre del consell assessor de l'elèctrica que presideix David Madí, qui fou gran estrateg d'Artur Mas a CDC. Miquel Roca Junyent, a qui li corresponia ser hereu de Jordi Pujol, des del seu bufet d'advocats ha sabut crear vincles valuosos, com ser conseller independent, per un sou de 308.378 euros. No hauríem d'oblidar tot un emblema de la Transició, de com la va conduir la dreta, com ara Rodolfo Martín Villa, exministre d'Interior i exvicepresident del govern, entre altres molts càrrecs amb la UCD, i que actualment, després d'haver estat a la filial xilena d'Endesa, n'és president d'honor. 

Iberdrola també ha anat a pescar a la política gent que es fa rebre i escoltar. Podríem començar amb aquell ministre de l'Interior que s'entestava a adjudicar l'atemptat terrorista del 14-M a ETA, Ángel Acebes, que ara potser no ha de recórrer a la seva vehemència com a membre del consell d'administració d'Iberdrola (216.000 euros anuals de retribució). 

Juan María Atutxa, exconseller d'Interior del PNB, dóna fe de la diversitat política en la nòmina de consellers d'Iberdrola, talment com Manuel Marín, socialista expresident del Congrés dels Diputats i exvicepresident de la Comissió Europea, que presideix la Fundació Iberdrola. Un altre gran puntal és Braulio Medel, antic cervell econòmic dels socialistes a Andalusia, que és conseller independent de l'elèctrica (297.000 euros de retribució). A Gas Natural Fenosa, segur que era significada al consell, com a representant de Repsol, la presència d'un exsecretari general d'Energia i Recursos Minerals amb Aznar, Nemesio Fernández Cuesta. En representació de Criteria Caixaholding, al consell hi ha Heribert Padrol, exnúmero dos de la llista de CiU al Congrés (126.500 euros de retribució anual). Cristina Garmendia, antiga ministra de Ciència i Innovació amb els socialistes, és una altra presència destacada del consell. El ministre que no va saber, o no va voler, observar que venia la crisi, el socialista Pedro Solbes, és conseller d'Enel, accionista de referència a Endesa, amb un sou de 132.000 euros. Red Eléctrica Española (REE) és també un altre gran cementiri d'elefants remunerats amb 150.000.180.000 euros anuals, amb noms ben significatius com ara Ángeles Amador, exministra de Sanitat amb el PSOE; Ana Cuevas, antiga cap de gabinet de la secretaria d'estat d'Energia i Desenvolupament Industrial amb el PP; Paloma Sendín, exdirectora general de Mines amb el PP, o el mateix president de la cotitzada, José Folgado, que amb els populars va ocupar el càrrec de secretari d'estat d'Economia, Energia i Pressupostos. Abengoa, ara tan necessitada de liquiditat per esquivar la fallida, també ha recorregut a exalts càrrecs de l'administració, com ara Luis Solana, exdiputat socialista i antic director de RTVE, i José Domínguez Abascal, exalt càrrec de la Junta d'Andalusia. A Enagás hi trobem noms com ara Antonio Hernández Mancha, exlíder d'Alianza Popular, i Isabel Tocino, exministra de Medi Ambient amb el PP. 

http://www.leconomic.cat/neco/article/4-economia/18-economia/930983-lobbisme-des-de-la-politica.html

8.2.16

Zygmunt Bauman: “Social media are a trap”





The Polish-born sociologist is skeptical about the possibilities for political change

Zygmunt Bauman has just celebrated his 90th birthday and taken two flights from his home in the northern British city of Leeds to get to an event in Burgos, northern Spain. He admits to being tired as we begin the interview, but he still manages to express his ideas calmly and clearly, taking his time with each response because he hates giving simple answers to complex questions. Since developing his theory of liquid modernity in the late 1990s – which describes our age as one in which “all agreements are temporary, fleeting, and valid only until further notice” – he has become a leading figure in the field of sociology. His work on inequality and his critique of what he sees as the failure of politics to meet people’s expectations, along with a highly pessimistic view of the future of society, have been picked up by the so-called May 15 “Indignant” movement in Spain – although he has repeatedly highlighted its weaknesses.
Zygmunt Bauman
Born in Poland in 1925, Bauman’s parents fled to the Soviet Union following the German invasion in 1939. In 1968, after he was stripped of his post as a teacher and expelled from the Communist Party along with thousands of other Jews in the wake of the Six-Day War, he left for the United Kingdom, taking up a post at Leeds University where he is now Emeritus Professor of Sociology. His work has been awarded numerous international prizes, among them Spain’s Prince of Asturias Award, in 2010.
He has outlined his pessimistic world view in books such as 2014’s Does the Richness of the Few Benefit Us All?, which argues that the world is paying a high price for the neoliberal revolution that began in the 1980s and that wealth has not trickled down to the rest of society. In Moral Blindness, published last year, he and co-author Leonidas Donskis warn about the loss of community in our increasingly individualistic world.
QUESTION. You have described inequality as a “metastasis.” Is democracy under threat?
ANSWER. We could describe what is going on at the moment as a crisis of democracy, the collapse of trust: the belief that our leaders are not just corrupt or stupid, but inept. Action requires power, to be able to do things, and we need politics, which is the ability to decide what needs to be done. But that marriage between power and politics in the hands of the nation state has ended. Power has been globalized, but politics is as local as before. Politics has had its hands cut off. People no longer believe in the democratic system because it doesn’t keep its promises. We see this, for example, with the migration crisis: it’s a global phenomenon, but we still act parochially. Our democratic institutions were not designed for dealing with situations of interdependence. The current crisis of democracy is a crisis of democratic institutions.
Q. In which direction is the pendulum that you describe between freedom and security swinging at the moment?
A. These are two values that are tremendously difficult to reconcile. If you want more security, you’re going to have to give up a certain amount of freedom; if you want more freedom, you’re going to have to give up security. This dilemma is going to continue forever. Forty years ago we believed that freedom had triumphed and we began an orgy of consumerism. Everything seemed possible by borrowing money: cars, homes… and you just paid for it later. The wakeup call in 2008 was a bitter one, when the loans dried up. The catastrophe, the social collapse that followed hit the middle classes particularly hard, dragging them into a precarious situation where they remain: they don’t know if their company is going to merge with another and they will be laid off, they don’t know if what they have bought really belongs to them… Conflict is no longer between classes, but between each person and society. It isn’t just a lack of security, but a lack of freedom.
Q. You say that progress is a myth, because people no longer believe the future will be better than the past.
A. We are in a period of interregnum, between a time when we had certainties and another when the old ways of doing things no longer work. We don’t know what is going to replace this. We are experimenting with new ways of doing things. Spain tried questioning things through the May 15 (15M) movement, when people took over public spaces, arguing, trying to replace parliamentary procedures with a kind of direct democracy. This hasn’t lasted long. Austerity policies will continue, nobody could stop them, but they could still be relatively effective in finding new ways to do things.
Q. You have argued that the likes of 15M and the global Occupy movement know “how to clear the way, but not how to create something solid.”
A. People set aside their differences for a while in the public squares for a common goal. If that goal is negative, about getting angry with someone, there is more chance of success. In a way it could have been an explosion of solidarity, but explosions are very powerful and short-lived.
Q. You also believe that by their nature, there is no room for leadership in rainbow coalitions.
A. It is precisely because such movements lack leaders that they can survive, but it is also precisely because they lack leaders that they cannot convert their sense of purpose into action.
Q. In Spain, the 15M movement has helped create new political forces.
A. Changing one party for another will not solve the problem. The problem is not that the parties are wrong, but that they don’t control things. Spain’s problems are part of a global problem. It’s a mistake to think you can solve things internally.
Q. What do you think about the Catalan independence project?
A. I think we’re still following the principles of Versailles, when the idea of each nation’s right to self rule was established. But that’s a fiction in today’s world, when there are no more homogeneous territories. Today, every society is just a collection of diasporas. People join the societies to which they are loyal and pay their taxes, but at the same time, they do not want to give up their identity. The connection between where you live and identity has been broken. The situation in Catalonia, as in Scotland or Lombardy, is a contradiction between tribal identity and citizenship. They are Europeans, but they don’t want to talk to Brussels via Madrid, but via Barcelona. The same logic is emerging in almost every country. We are still following the same principles established at the end of World War I, but there have been many changes in the world.
Q. You are skeptical of the way people protest through social media, of so-called “armchair activism,” and say that the internet is dumbing us down with cheap entertainment. So would you say that the social networks are the new opium of the people?
A. The question of identity has changed from being something you are born with to a task: you have to create your own community. But communities aren’t created, and you either have one or you don’t. What the social networks can create is a substitute. The difference between a community and a network is that you belong to a community, but a network belongs to you. You feel in control. You can add friends if you wish, you can delete them if you wish. You are in control of the important people to whom you relate. People feel a little better as a result, because loneliness, abandonment, is the great fear in our individualist age. But it’s so easy to add or remove friends on the internet that people fail to learn the real social skills, which you need when you go to the street, when you go to your workplace, where you find lots of people who you need to enter into sensible interaction with. Pope Francis, who is a great man, gave his first interview after being elected to Eugenio Scalfari, an Italian journalist who is also a self-proclaimed atheist. It was a sign: real dialogue isn’t about talking to people who believe the same things as you. Social media don’t teach us to dialogue because it is so easy to avoid controversy… But most people use social media not to unite, not to open their horizons wider, but on the contrary, to cut themselves a comfort zone where the only sounds they hear are the echoes of their own voice, where the only things they see are the reflections of their own face. Social media are very useful, they provide pleasure, but they are a trap.

7.2.16

BUILDING A BUSINESS OF POLITICS



  • Hardcover: 296 pages
    • Publisher: OUP USA (28 Jan. 2016)
    • Language: English
    • ISBN-10: 0190217197
    • ISBN-13: 978-0190217198

    Building a Business of Politics: The Rise of Political Consulting and the Transformation of American Democracy 


    Since the early twentieth century, political races in the United States have relied on highly paid political consultants to carefully curate the perceived personalities of hopeful politicians, to advise candidates using polling and analytics, and to affect voters' perceptions with marketing and advertising techniques. Much of the $1.3 billion spent in the 2012 presidential election went to these consultants who control virtually every aspect of the campaigns from polling, fundraising, and media to more novel techniques of social media and micro-targeting. These consultants play a larger role in our political races than ever before-determining not only how the public sees politicians, but also how politicians see the public. 

    In Building a Business of Politics¸ author Adam Sheingate traces the history of political consultants back to the Progressive Era at the turn of the twentieth century, when reformers viewed increased publicity as a positive way to further open politics up to public scrutiny. Through the following century, the addition of publicity to politics transformed political races into a very profitable business. Consultants command a hefty fee from politicians and in turn leverage the perceived message of the politician into increased special interest group campaign donations. In fact, critics often blame these consultants for the state of politics today. 

    The implications of this system on the state of American democracy are significant: the rise of the permanent campaign brings with it the rise of a permanent campaign industry, thus affecting the priorities of politicians. A professional political class stands between the voters and those who claim to represent them, influencing messages on both sides. This book shows how the character of our politics depends on who controls these vital aspects of democratic practice, and what this means for the future of our political system.

    Preface

    1.) The Business of Politics
    2.) Publicity and the Public
    3.) Professional Propaganda
    4.) The Art and Science of Politics
    5.) A Business Takes Shape
    6.) Advertising Politics
    7.) The Consolidation of Control 
    8.) The Business of Digital Politics
    9.) The Evolution of Political Work

    Appendix: Estimating the Size of the Political Consulting Industry
    Notes
    Index

     Adam Sheingate
    Sheingate_headshot

    Adam Sheingate is an associate professor and chair of Political Science at Johns Hopkins University. His most recent book is Building a Business of Politics: The Rise of Political Consulting and the Transformation of American Democracy. His is also a co-editor of theOxford Handbook of Historical Institutionalism and the author of the Rise of the Agricultural Welfare State: Institutions and Interest Group Power in the United States, France, and Japan as well as journal articles and book chapters on American political development, historical institutionalism, and comparative public policy.
     Sheingate teaches courses on American politics and institutions at the graduate and undergraduate level, including a popular seminar on the politics of food. Prior to joining the Johns Hopkins University faculty, Sheingate was a Prize Research Fellow in Politics at Nuffield College, Oxford. He is also a past-recipient of a Robert Wood Johnson Foundation Scholar Award in Health Policy Research at the University of California-Berkeley, and he served as the Mary Ball Washington Professor in American History at University College Dublin.

    2.1.16

    THE SOCIAL MEDIA PRESIDENT

    The Social Media President
    Prominent in Barack Obama's political campaigns and presidency has been a promise to use social media tools to engage American citizens in the business of democratic governance, stirring the hopes of millions who believe in the democratizing potential of information and communication technology. Yet what has become of these promises? To what extent have they been realized? Shattering views of social media as a cure-all for limits on citizen deliberation and governmental representation, The Social Media President: Barack Obama and the Politics of Digital Engagementanalyzes the White House's use of Twitter and other online tools for a wide range of policy initiatives and strategic campaigns. Drawing on interviews, case studies and social-media content, the authors provide a bold take on a subject too frequently prone to exaggerated expectations. By examining presidential campaigns since 1992 and the actions of President Obama since taking office in 2009, a clearer picture emerges about the strengths and weaknesses of social media for public engagement. In terms of setting national policy, or getting systematic citizen input, a social media-enabled future would not only be difficult to implement with foreseeable technology, it could actually erode democratic institutions of voting and representation. Yet social media's prominence continues to grow and it is destined to play an ever-larger role in political rhetoric, campaign strategies, governance appeals and public debate. The thoughtful attention the authors provide to the successes, limitations and missed opportunities of the Obama Administration should command the interest of concerned scholars, practitioners and citizens everywhere.

    PART I: THE HOPE FOR SOCIAL MEDIA IN GOVERNMENT
    1. A Wonderful Illusion: Citizen Participation in the Obama Era
    2. Scholarship of the New Media Landscape
    3. New Media and Electoral Politics: An Abbreviated History
    4. The Social Media President
    PART II: BABY STEPS, DISSAPOINTMENTS, AND POLITICAL GAMES
    5. The Citizen's Briefing Book
    6. White House Online Town Hall
    7. Expert Labs
    8. The Supreme Court Vacancies and the Health Care Debate
    9. President OBama and the Government
    10. Social Media, Policy, and Transparency
    PART III: ASSESSING PRESIDENT OBAMA'S SOCIAL-MEDIA INITIATIVES
    11. A Changes Focus
    12. Analytical Perspective
    13. Conclusion and Implications

    James E. Katz, Ph.D., is the Feld Family Professor of Emerging Media at Boston University's College of Communication where he also he directs its Division of Emerging Media Studies. Prior to coming to Boston, Katz was the Board of Governors Professor of Communication at Rutgers University. Winner of numerous awards for his scholarship on communication technology, including a lifetime achievement award from the American Sociological Association, Katz is frequently invited to keynote international conferences. His books include the Handbook of Mobile Communication Studies and Magic in the Air: Mobile Communication and the Transformation of Social Life. 

    Michael Barris is a New York-based reporter covering international business news for the online, video and print markets. His background includes working for Dow Jones Newswires where he was a regular contributor to the Wall Street Journal. He holds a master's degree in communication from Rutgers University. 

    Anshul Jain is currently completing his doctorate in political science at Boston University. His research interests broadly span the fields of political communication, international relations, American politics, and history. Anshul previously taught with the Boston public schools and is a graduate of Duke University. 

    ISBN9781137380845
    Publication DateDecember 2013
    FormatsPaperback Hardcover Ebook (EPUB) Ebook (PDF) 
    PublisherPalgrave Macmillan

    28.12.15

    Social Media and Conflict Zones: The New Evidence Base For Policymaking

    January 20, 2015
    Originally posted on King’s College London’s Policy Institute blog Policy Wonkers.
    In recent years, content shared via social media from conflict war zones has allowed us to gain a far deeper understanding of the on-the-ground realities of specific conflicts than previously possible. This presents a real opportunity for providing robust evidence which can underpin foreign and security policymaking about emerging, or rapidly escalating, conflict zones. Despite this opportunity, however, policymakers have generally been slow to adapt to the volume of information disseminated on social media from various armed groups in Syria and slower still to use this as an evidence base for policy generation.
    In the case of the Syrian conflict, for example, far more information in the public domain comes not from journalists on the ground (who, it goes without saying face extreme danger in attempting to report from many parts of Syria) but from social media and user generated content online.
    In 2012, the video streaming site Bambuser was adopted by groups opposing the Syrian government to livestream videos of protests and violence from across Syria. The situation changed as violence escalated and internet access in opposition-controlled areas became increasingly limited. Today, this means that the vast majority of social media accounts being used by the Syrian opposition are associated with specific locations, media centres, or armed groups. This provides researchers with a real opportunity to understand the actors and events taking place on the ground.
    This approach has its advantages: because comparatively few people in opposition areas are using social media, and they tend to be associated with specific groups, it is possible to collect and organise the majority of the social media accounts that are being used in opposition controlled areas. These accounts can be monitored for activity, and cover the majority of information coming from opposition controlled areas through social media. This can provide a detailed and dynamic picture of the conflict as well as a detailed understanding of the various armed groups.
    There are challenges in this approach, however. The most obvious, in the Syrian context, is that researchers are limited to what those groups post online – and perhaps more importantly, that this often represents a narrow perspective on the conflict in opposition areas. A second problem is neatly illustrated by the Bellingcat research on the current conflict in Ukraine. Here, the opposite is true: because internet access is not limited, anyone can post anything they like online and they can post to a wider variety of social media sites. Granted, this vast amount of information posted from a huge variety of sources provides a richer picture, but it is also one that is harder to access through the ‘noise’ of other material.
    Open source intelligence analysis has the potential not only to inform us about various actors and events on the ground, but also to allow us to piece together disparate pieces of information into a wider, more investigative, piece of research. In Bellingcat’s MH17 investigation, the research team compiled information from dozens of different sources, discovered by searching through thousands of social media accounts from Ukraine and Russia, on a wide variety of social media sites. Using this information it was possible to track the movements of a Buk missile launcher on July 17th through separatist-controlled territory to the likely launch site of the missile that downed MH17. The team was also able to find videos from multiple sources of exactly the same missile launcher travelling as part of a convoy through Russia towards the Ukrainian border a few weeks before MH17 was downed. The evidence was sufficiently robust to allow us to conclude that the Buk seen in Ukraine on July 17th originated from the Russian military.
    Our research on the Buk missile launcher demonstrates that not only is there a wealth of largely untapped information available online and especially on social media, but also that a relatively small team of analysts is able to derive a rich picture of a conflict zone. Clearly, research of this kind must be underpinned by an understanding of the way in which content is being produced, who is sharing it, and, crucially, how to verify it – and these are methodological challenges which need to be addressed systematically. Nonetheless, the overarching point is that there is a real opportunity for open source intelligence analysis to provide the kind of evidence base that can underpin effective and successful foreign and security policymaking. It is an opportunity that policymakers should seize.
    Eliot Higgins is the founder of Bellingcat and the Brown Moses Blog. Eliot focuses on the weapons used in the conflict in Syria, and open source investigation tools and techniques.

    Commentary:
    Steve

    Speaking of systematic methodology, how would it be to validate the source of pictures and obtain originals, instead of working with copies.
    The issue I see with these OSINT approaches is, that there is absolutely no way of trusting relationships, like in real intelligence scenarios.
    The simple reason is lack of accountability due to anonymous sources… These resources have a great potential, but relying real world policy questions on them is very dangerous, as these are mostly not marketing based topics, but effecting peoples lives.

    You can be sure, that intelligence agencies are ahead of your ideas of sourcing open information and more importantly connecting them.
    But they simply have to be accountable for their results, so have to omit a lot of information which simply isn’t possible to verify.

    So trying to emulate these methods through crowds is very naive, as it will simply just be another opinion generator and multiplier.
    Obviously your company will be able to generate some money with this, by selling these “investigations” to news outlets, but this will only lead to a further deterioration of journalism, which will not have the resources to actually investigate topics.
    So you might call this revolutionary, I would call this the wet dream of every