5.1.14

How Your Data Are Being Deeply Mined

09.01.2014

Alice E. Marwick


http://www.nybooks.com/articles/archives/2014/jan/09/how-your-data-are-being-deeply-mined/?pagination=false&printpage=true


The recent revelations regarding the NSA’s collection of the personal information and the digital activities of millions of people across the world have attracted immense attention and public concern. But there are equally troubling and equally opaque systems run by advertising, marketing, and data-mining firms that are far less known. Using techniques ranging from supermarket loyalty cards to targeted advertising on Facebook, private companies systematically collect very personal information, from who you are, to what you do, to what you buy. Data about your online and offline behavior are combined, analyzed, and sold to marketers, corporations, governments, and even criminals. The scope of this collection, aggregation, and brokering of information is similar to, if not larger than, that of the NSA, yet it is almost entirely unregulated and many of the activities of data-mining and digital marketing firms are not publicly known at all.

Here I will discuss two things: the involuntary, or passive, collecting of data by private corporations; and the voluntary, or active, collection and aggregation of their own personal data by individuals. While I think it is the former that we should be more concerned with, the latter poses the question of whether it is possible for us to take full advantage of social media without playing into larger corporate interests.

Database Marketing
The industry of collecting, aggregating, and brokering personal data is known as “database marketing.” The second-largest company in this field, Acxiom, has 23,000 computer servers that process more than 50 trillion data transactions per year, according to The New York Times.1 It claims to have records on hundreds of millions of Americans, including 1.1 billion browser cookies (small pieces of data sent from a website, used to track the user’s activity), 200 million mobile profiles, and an average of 1,500 pieces of data perconsumer. These data include information gleaned from publicly available records like home valuation and vehicle ownership, information about online behavior tracked through cookies, browser advertising, and the like, data from customer surveys, and “offline” buying behavior. The CEO, Scott Howe, says, “Our digital reach will soon approach nearly every Internet user in the US.”2

Visiting virtually any website places a digital cookie, or small text file, on your computer. “First-party” cookies are placed by the site itself, such as Gmail saving your password so that you don’t have to log in every time you visit the site. “Third-party cookies” persist across sites, tracking what sites you visit, in what order. For those who have logged in, Google Chrome and Firefox sync this browsing history across devices, combining what you do on your iPad with your iPhone with your laptop. This is used to deliver advertising.

For example, a few nights ago I was browsing LLBean.com for winter boots on my iPhone. A few days later, LLBean.com ads showed up on a news blog I was reading on my iPad. This “behavioral targeting” is falling out of fashion in favor of “predictive targeting,” which uses sophisticated data-mining techniques to predict for L.L.Bean whether or not I am likely to purchase something upon seeing an LLBean.com ad.

Acxiom provides “premium proprietary behavioral insights” that “number in the thousands and cover consumer interests ranging from brand and channel affinities to product usage and purchase timing.” In other words, Acxiom creates profiles, or digital dossiers, about millions of people, based on the 1,500 points of data about them it claims to have. These data might include your education level; how many children you have; the type of car you drive; your stock portfolio; your recent purchases; and your race, age, and education level. These data are combined across sources—for instance, magazine subscriber lists and public records of home ownership—to determine whether you fit into a number of predefined categories such as “McMansions and Minivans” or “adult with wealthy parent.”3 Acxiom is then able to sell these consumer profiles to its customers, who include twelve of the top fifteen credit card issuers, seven of the top ten retail banks, eight of the top ten telecom/media companies, and nine of the top ten property and casualty insurers.

Acxiom may be one of the largest data brokers, but it represents a dramatic shift in the way that personal information is handled online. The movement toward “Big Data,” which uses computational techniques to find social insights in very large groupings of data, is rapidly transforming industries from health care to electoral politics. Big Data has many well-known social uses, for example by the police and by managers aiming to increase productivity. But it also poses new challenges to privacy on an unprecedented level and scale. Big Data is made up of “little data,” and these little data may be deeply personal.
Alone, the fact that you purchased a bottle of cocoa butter lotion from Target is unremarkable. Target, on the other hand, assigns each customer a single Guest ID number, linked to their credit card number, e-mail address, or name. Every purchase and interaction you have with Target is then linked to your Guest ID, including the cocoa butter.

Now, Target has spent a great deal of time figuring out how to market to people about to have a baby. While most people remain fairly constant in their shopping habits—buying toilet paper here, socks there—the birth of a child is a life change that brings immense upheaval. Since birth records are public, new parents are bombarded with marketing and advertising offers. So Target’s goal was to identify parents before the baby was born. The chief statistician for Target, Andrew Pole, said, “We knew that if we could identify [new parents] in their second trimester, there’s a good chance we could capture them for years.”4 Pole had been mining immense amounts of data about the shopping habits of pregnant women and new parents. He found that women purchased certain things during their pregnancy, such as cocoa butter, calcium tablets, and large purses that could double as diaper bags.

Target then began sending targeted mail to women during their pregnancy. This backfired. Women found it creepy—how did Target know they were pregnant? In one famous case, the father of a teenage girl called Target to complain that it was encouraging teen pregnancy by mailing her coupons for car seats and diapers. A week later, he called back and apologized; she hadn’t told her father yet that she was pregnant.5

So the Target managers changed their tactics. They mixed in coupons for wine and lawnmowers with those for pacifiers and Baby Wipes. Pregnant women could use the coupons without realizing that Target knew they were pregnant. As Pole told The New York Times Magazine, “Even if you’re following the law, you can do things where people get queasy.”

These same techniques were used to great effect by the Obama campaign before the 2012 election. Famously, the campaign recruited some of the most brilliant young experts in analytics and behavioral science, and put them in a room called “the cave” for sixteen hours a day.6 The chief data scientist for the campaign was an analyst who had formerly mined Big Data to improve supermarket promotions. This “dream team” was able to deliver microtargeted demographics to Obama—they could predict exactly how much money they would get back from each fund-raising e-mail. When the team discovered that East Coast women between thirty and forty were not donating as much as might be expected, they offered a chance to have dinner with Sarah Jessica Parker as an incentive.7 Every evening, the campaign ran 66,000 simulations to model the state of the election. The Obama analysts were not only using cutting-edge database marketing techniques, they were developing techniques that were far beyond the state of the art.

The Obama campaign’s tactics illuminate something that is often missed in our discussions of data-mining and marketing—the fact that governments and politicians are major clients of marketing agencies and data brokers. For instance, the campaign bought data on the television-watching habits of Ohioans from a company called FourthWallMedia. Each household was assigned a number, but the names of those in the household were not revealed. The Obama campaign, however, was able to combine lists of voters with lists of cable subscribers, which it could then coordinate with the supposedly anonymous ID numbers used to track the usage patterns of television set-top boxes.8 It could then target campaign ads to the exact times that certain voters were watching television. As a result, the campaign bought airtime during unconventional programming, like Sons of Anarchy, The Walking Dead, and Don’t Trust the B— in Apt. 23, rather than during local news programming as conventional wisdom would have advised.

The “cave dwellers” were even able to match voter lists with Facebook information, using “Facebook Connect,” Facebook’s sign-on technology, which is used for many sign-ups and commenting systems online. Knowing that some of these users were Obama supporters, the campaign could figure out how to get them to persuade their perhaps less motivated friends to vote. Observing lists of Facebook friends and comparing them with tagged photos, the campaign matched these “friends” with lists of persuadable voters and then mobilized Obama supporters to convince their “real-life” friends to vote.

Social Media
In view of these sophisticated data- mining and analyzing techniques, is there any way we can use social media—or the Internet itself —without adding to our profiles collected by companies like Acxiom, Experian, or Epsilon?

Social media allow us to collect and track data about ourselves. For instance, I have been using a website called Last.fm since 2005 to track every piece of digital music I have listened to when using iTunes or Spotify. As a result, I have a fascinating picture of how my musical tastes have changed over time, and Last.fm is able to recommend obscure bands to me based on this extensive listening history.

Using social media allows us to connect with friends; to learn more about ourselves; even to improve our lives. The Quantified Self movement, which builds on techniques used by women for decades, such as counting calories, promotes the use of personal data for self-knowledge. Measuring your sleep cycles over time, for instance, can help you learn to avoid caffeine after 4:00 pm, or realize that, if you want to fall asleep, you can’t use the Internet for an hour before bedtime.

But these data are immensely beneficial to data brokers. Imagine how a health insurer might react to viewing your caloric intake on MyFitnessPal, the number of steps you walk per day tracked by Fitbit, how often you check in to your local gym using Foursquare, and what you eat based on the pictures of your meals that you post on Instagram. Each piece of information, by itself, may be inconsequential, but the aggregation of this information creates a larger picture. Data trackers can centrally access such information and add it to their databases. Two large consequences of this collection of data deserve more attention.

The first is data discrimination. Once customers are sliced and diced into segmented demographic categories, they can be sorted. An Acxiom presentation to the Consumer Marketing Organization in 2013 placed customers into “customer value segments” and noted that while the top 30 percent of customers add 500 percent of value, the bottom 20 percent actually cost 400 percent of value. In other words, it behooves companies to shower their top customers with attention, while ignoring the bottom 20 percent, who may spend “too much” time on customer service calls, and may cost companies in returns or coupons, or otherwise cost more than they provide.

These “low-value targets” are known in industry parlance as “waste.” Joseph Turow, a University of Pennsylvania professor in communications who studies niche marketing, asks what happens to those people who fall into the categories of “waste,” entirely without their knowledge or any notification. Do they suffer price discrimination? Poor service? Do they miss out on the offers given to others? Such discrimination is still more insidious because it is entirely invisible.

Second, we may be more concerned with government surveillance than with marketers or data brokers collecting personal information, but this ignores the fact that the government regularly purchases data from these companies. ChoicePoint, now owned by Elsevier, was an enormous data aggregator that combined personal data extracted from public and private databases, including Social Security numbers, credit reports, and criminal records. It maintained 17 billion records on businesses and individuals, which it sold to approximately 100,000 clients, including thirty-five government agencies and seven thousand federal, state, and local law enforcement agencies.9

For instance, the State Department purchased records on millions of Latin American citizens, which were then checked against immigration databases. Choicepoint was also investigated for selling 145,000 personal records to an identity theft ring. More recently, Experian, one of the three major credit bureaus, mistakenly sold personal records to a Vietnamese hacker. Scammers refer to these records, which include Social Security numbers and mothers’ maiden names, as “fullz,” because they contain enough personal information for crooked operators to apply for credit cards or take out loans.

A few years ago, I toured the experimental lab of a large advertising agency. They showed me the cutting edge of consumer- monitoring technologies. Someday, not too far in the future, if you’re at Duane Reade, aimlessly staring at a giant shelf of shampoo trying to figure out which to buy, the shelf will track your eye movements and which bottles you pick up and examine in more detail. Using this data, Duane Reade can algorithmically generate a coupon for a particular brand of shampoo, which you can then print from the shelf. I watched an experimental application that tracks the movements of individuals through a mall, based on the unique identifiers, or MAC addresses, of their cell phones, kept in purses or pockets but available to wireless tracking devices. Again, in all of these cases, the individuals are unaware that they are being tracked. A description of such procedures may be hidden at the end of a byzantine privacy policy people may not have noticed when they bought their devices, or written on a notice next to a CCTV camera. Though they may not be technically illegal, they seem ethically dubious.

While the easy answer to these problems is to opt out of loyalty cards, Internet use, or social media, this is hardly realistic. In fact, it is practically impossible to live life, online or offline, without being tracked—unless one takes extreme measures of avoidance. Cities track car movements; radio-frequency identification (RFID) tags are attached to clothing and dry cleaning; CCTV cameras are in most stores.10 The technology is developing far more rapidly than our consumer protection laws, which in many cases are out of date and difficult to apply to our networked world.

The Federal Trade Commission and the Senate Commerce Committee are currently investigating data brokers and calling for more transparency in the collection and dissemination of personal information. Those of us concerned with privacy must continue to demand that checks and balances be applied to these private corporations. People should be encouraged to investigate the various opt- out tools, ad-blockers, and plug-ins that are available for most platforms. While closer scrutiny of the NSA is necessary and needed, we must apply equal pressure to private corporations to ensure that seemingly harmless targeted mail campaigns and advertisements do not give way to insidious and dangerous violations of personal privacy.

1 See Natasha Singer, “Acxiom, the Quiet Giant of Consumer Database Marketing,” The New York Times, June 16, 2012. ↩
2 See Judith Aquino, “ Acxiom Prepares New ‘Audience Operating System’ Amid Wobbly Earnings,” AdExchanger.com, August 1, 2013. ↩ 
3 See Natasha Singer, “A Data Broker Offers a Peek Behind the Curtain,” The New York Times, August 31, 2013. ↩ 
4 See Charles Duhigg, “How Companies Learn Your Secrets,” The New York Times Magazine, February 16, 2012. ↩ 
5 See Kashmir Hill, “ How Target Figured Out a Teen Girl Was Pregnant Before Her Father Did,” Forbes, February 16, 2012. ↩ 
6 See Jim Rutenberg, “ Data You Can Believe In: The Obama Campaign’s Digital Masterminds Cash In,” The New York Times Magazine, June 20, 2013. ↩ 
7 See Michael Scherer, “ Inside the Secret World of the Data Crunchers Who Helped Obama Win,” Time, November 7, 2012. ↩ 
8 See Lois Beckett, “ Everything We Know (So Far) About Obama’s Big Data Tactics,” ProPublica, November 29, 2012. ↩
9 See “ ChoicePoint,” at the Electronic Privacy Information Center. ↩ 
10 See Sarah Kessler, “ Think You Can Live Offline Without Being Tracked? Here’s What It Takes,” Fast Company, October 15, 2013. ↩

Listen to Pandora, and It Listens Back


04.01.2014
Pandora, the Internet radio service, is plying a new tune.
After years of customizing playlists to individual listeners by analyzing components of the songs they like, then playing them tracks with similar traits, the company has started data-mining users’ musical tastes for clues about the kinds of ads most likely to engage them.
“It’s becoming quite apparent to us that the world of playing the perfect music to people and the world of playing perfect advertising to them are strikingly similar,” says Eric Bieschke, Pandora’s chief scientist.
Consider someone who’s in an adventurous musical mood on a weekend afternoon, he says. One hypothesis is that this listener may be more likely to click on an ad for, say, adventure travel in Costa Rica than a person in an office on a Monday morning listening to familiar tunes. And that person at the office, Mr. Bieschke says, may be more inclined to respond to a more conservative travel ad for a restaurant-and-museum tour of Paris. Pandora is now testing hypotheses like these by, among other methods, measuring the frequency of ad clicks. “There are a lot of interesting things we can do on the music side that bridge the way to advertising,” says Mr. Bieschke, who led the development of Pandora’s music recommendation engine.
A few services, like Pandora, Amazon and Netflix, were early in developing algorithms to recommend products based on an individual customer’s preferences or those of people with similar profiles. Now, some companies are trying to differentiate themselves by using their proprietary data sets to make deeper inferences about individuals and try to influence their behavior.
This online ad customization technique is known as behavioral targeting, but Pandora adds a music layer. Pandora has collected song preference and other details about more than 200 million registered users, and those people have expressed their song likes and dislikes by pressing the site’s thumbs-up and thumbs-down buttons more than 35 billion times. Because Pandora needs to understand the type of device a listener is using in order to deliver songs in a playable format, its system also knows whether people are tuning in from their cars, from iPhones or Android phones or from desktops.
So it seems only logical for the company to start seeking correlations between users’ listening habits and the kinds of ads they might be most receptive to.
“The advantage of using our own in-house data is that we have it down to the individual level, to the specific person who is using Pandora,” Mr. Bieschke says. “We take all of these signals and look at correlations that lead us to come up with magical insights about somebody.”
People’s music, movie or book choices may reveal much more than commercial likes and dislikes. Certain product or cultural preferences can give glimpses into consumers’ political beliefs, religious faith, sexual orientation or other intimate issues. That means many organizations now are not merely collecting details about where we go and what we buy, but are also making inferences about who we are.
“I would guess, looking at music choices, you could probably predict with high accuracy a person’s worldview,” says Vitaly Shmatikov, an associate professor of computer science at the University of Texas at Austin, where he studies computer security and privacy. “You might be able to predict people’s stance on issues like gun control or the environment because there are bands and music tracks that do express strong positions.”
Pandora, for one, has a political ad-targeting system that has been used in presidential and congressional campaigns, and even a few for governor. It can deconstruct users’ song preferences to predict their political party of choice. (The company does not analyze listeners’ attitudes to individual political issues like abortion or fracking.)
During the next federal election cycle, for instance, Pandora users tuning into country music acts, stand-up comedians or Christian bands might hear or see ads for Republican candidates for Congress. Others listening to hip-hop tunes, or to classical acts like the Berlin Philharmonic, might hear ads for Democrats.
Because Pandora users provide their ZIP codes when they register, Mr. Bieschke says, “we can play ads only for the specific districts political campaigns want to target,” and “we can use their music to predict users’ political affiliations.” But he cautioned that the predictions about users’ political parties are machine-generated forecasts for groups of listeners with certain similar characteristics and may not be correct for any particular listener.
Shazam, the song recognition app with 80 million unique monthly users, also plays ads based on users’ preferred music genres. “Hypothetically, a Ford F-150 pickup truck might over-index to country music listeners,” says Kevin McGurn, Shazam’s chief revenue officer. For those who prefer U2 and Coldplay, a demographic that skews to middle-age people with relatively high incomes, he says, the app might play ads for luxury cars like Jaguars.
In its privacy policy, Pandora describes the types of information it collects about users and the purposes — music personalization and ad customization — for which the information may be employed. Although users may elect to pay $36 annually to opt out of receiving ads, advertising on the free service accounts for the bulk of Pandora’s revenue. Out of $427.1 million in revenue in the 2013 fiscal year, advertising generated $375.2 million.
Pandora’s inferences about individuals become more discerning as time goes on. How we think about the ethics and accuracy of algorithms is another matter.
“I’m optimistic that the benefits to society will outweigh the risks,” Professor Shmatikov says. “But our attitudes will have to evolve to understand that now everybody knows more about who we are.”

7.9.13

Soroll real al PSC

Article publicat al Diari de Girona el 29 d'agost del 2013
Xavier Pastor

La carta d'Antoni Balmón-alcalde de Cornellà de Llobregat i des del 2011 membre de l'executiva del PSC-, criticant obertament les declaracions dels que ell anomena "els professionals de la polseguera" amb noms i cognoms que estan en contra del posicionament polític del partit sobre el dret a decidir, ha tingut una gran repercussió.

Després d'una allau de respostes públiques, especialment dels implicats i de molts altres militants del PSC, el portaveu socialista al Parlament, Maurici Lucena,ha instat als crítics amb la direcció del partit a rebaixar "el soroll artificial que no reflecteix la proporció de posicions internes del PSC".

Després de llegir Lucena, la carta de Balmón no és producte d'una decisió o una acció personal aïllada -ell és membre de l'executiva-, sinó una reacció contundent per evitar més desgast del secretari general del PSC, Pere Navarro, i per contrarestar mediàticament les informacions sobre els actes de l'11 de setembre.
A més aquest és un conflicte intern que dura molt de temps amb la participació de diferents implicats i en conseqüència gens artificial i molt real. Podem remuntar-nos com a mínim a quan el PSC es trobava en el govern de la Generalitat, i potser molt abans, durant la campanya de les eleccions catalanes del 2003 quan José Montilla i Miquel Iceta donen un ultimàtum a Pasqual Maragall i li diuen que si no guanya o governa haurà de plegar. Tanmateix, és en el Govern del Tripartit que les lluites i declaracions dels uns i els altres esdevenen públiques, per exemple, quan el PSC, el seu primer secretari, José Montilla, es va oposar a la remodelació del govern amb el conseqüent canvi de consellers per part del President Maragall (2005) o quan Antoni Castells, conseller d'economia del govern de Montilla, va dir que no volia anar a les llistes del PSC a les eleccions al Parlament (2010) o quan Pasqual Maragall (2010) va fer campanya per Artur Mas.
Des d'un dels corrents interns del Socialistes de Catalunya, en relació a la cadena humana que l'Assemblea Nacional Catalana organitzarà per l'Onze de Setembre, s'ha proposat donar llibertat d'acció al seus membres per assistir-hi o no.

Tanmateix, la llibertat d'acció i de vot no està ben vista al PSC i margina a qui la practica. A principis d'any en motiu de la votació de la Declaració de Sobirania al Parlament, cinc diputats van haver de sortir del ple per no haver de votar que no, posició que imposava el partit. Sis mesos abans, al juliol del 2012, Ernest Maragall, exconseller d'educació, en aquell moment encara diputat del PSC i membre de l'executiva, votava en contra dels seus companys a favor del Pacte fiscal i de la creació d'una hisenda catalana.
La llibertat d'acció i de vot del PSC tampoc és una solució en el context actual i per als interessos del país. La darrera vegada que al PSC es va donar llibertat de vot va ser per la llei en contra de les corrides de braus al 2011. La llei va superar la votació amb 68 vots a favor dels 135 del Parlament (32 de CiU, 3 del PSC-CpC, 21 d'ERC i els 12 ICV-EUiA).

La majoria dels diputats i diputades del PSC-CpC (31), del PP (14) i de Ciutadans (3) van votar en contra de la prohibició fent visibles quins són els punts en comú polítics d'aquests tres partits: els dos primers com a franquícies dels principals partits espanyols -PSOE i PP- i els tres junts, el predomini de la realitat i sensibilitat espanyola per davant de la catalana. Avui, el PSC continua pensant més amb Espanya i en el PSOE que en Catalunya, i el Partit continua per davant de la política, en concret dels polítics i dels diputats.

30.8.13

Marta Alonso: "En el món 2.0 s'avança tan de pressa que ni tan sols Google té la vida assegurada"

http://www.ara.cat/premium/opinio/MARTA-ALONSO-tan-Google-assegurada_0_983901606.html

Marta Alonso, responsable digital a la seu barcelonina d'Edelman -primera empresa de relacions públiques del món-, és també ideòloga del moviment igers





Marta Alonso (Barcelona, 1986) va penjar la seva primera foto a Instagram durant un sopar. Havia entrat a la xarxa social fotogràfica per excel·lència poc després que aparegués, a finals del 2010, quan encara no havia esclatat el boom. "Ja abans de fer la meva primera entrada a Instagram ja vaig veure que era una eina brutal de màrqueting i que era una potencial xarxa social d'emocions", assegura. Responsable digital a la seu barcelonina d'Edelman -primera empresa de relacions públiques del món-, és també ideòloga del moviment igers , que va començar a Barcelona i que ara ja aglutina 350 ciutats d'arreu del món.


Twitter et fa creure que ets enginyós, Facebook que tens amics i Instagram que ets un bon fotògraf, diuen.

Una de les principals virtuts d'Instagram és que democratitza la fotografia. El que més m'ha sorprès és trobar gent que en cap moment de la seva vida s'hauria plantejat agafar una càmera de fotos i que aquesta eina els fa veure que tenen un talent. N'hi ha que fins i tot han pogut protagonitzar exposicions.

Existeix un esclat del que anomenem social media .

Hi ha una nova via de comunicació, que són els mitjans socials. Els professionals que ens dediquem a això ajudem les marques a entendre aquesta nova comunicació bidireccional i a aprofitar l'oportunitat d'escoltar els seus usuaris per primera vegada.

Ara les empreses ja deuen haver entès que, sense tenir en compte això, estan perdudes.

Abans les marques impactaven sense saber el feeling del consumidor. Ara estem davant d'un moment de transformació: les xarxes socials no són una moda, no són una tendència puntual.

Per què?

Suposen una transformació que no només afecta la comunicació, sinó també les institucions, i que va encaminada cap al món digital. Han canviat les maneres de comunicar-se, els nostres hàbits i la nostra manera d'interactuar amb les persones.

Quins beneficis tangibles obtenen les marques que fan una bona gestió de les xarxes socials?

Els mitjans socials fan que els missatges arribin a més gent per uns costos més baixos que en mitjans tradicionals. Posem com a exemple la Catalunya Experience, un projecte de l'Agència Catalana de Turisme. Vam voler portar 10 instagramers reputats d'arreu del món perquè fessin d'ambaixadors de Catalunya. Gràcies a la seva experiència, reflectida a Instagram, vam tenir 20 milions d'impactes a la xarxa. Aquests impactes, en mitjans tradicionals, tindrien un cost incalculable.

Quines són les empreses que consideres que gestionen millor les eines de comunicació social?

A escala mundial, Starbucks sempre va al capdavant. Quan es llança una nova plataforma, les marques esperen molt la reacció dels grans playerspublicitaris. Si veuen que l'eina es consolida, fan el pas. Starbucks, quan ho té clar, tira milles, i ho fa molt bé, amb solidesa. Hi ha experiències que han sigut pioneres, com la retransmissió que va fer el Barça d'un partit a través d'Instagram, o la presentació d'un cotxe Ford per mitjà d'aquesta xarxa social.
La comunicació 2.0 és una bombolla que esclatarà?
No crec que estiguem parlant d'una bombolla, de debò. Sí que és veritat que la valoració de les empreses tecnològiques, que ara és de molts milions de dòlars, es pot arribar a estabilitzar. També s'ha de recordar que hi ha empreses que cauen pel camí. Ni tan sols Google té la vida assegurada. Aquest món avança tan ràpid que qui sap si d'aquí cinc anys hi haurà Facebook.
Com es construeix un bon perfil 2.0?
No crec en les receptes màgiques. Quan parlo amb les marques i les assessoro, m'agrada ser transparent i sincera. Primer de tot, s'ha de valorar si té sentit estar present en una determinada xarxa. No tothom ha de ser a Instagram, per exemple: només hi has d'entrar si tens alguna cosa a dir. Es necessita una estratègia, explicar els valors de la marca amb imatges, mostrar-te transparent, humà. Emocionar, en definitiva. Això s'anomena storytelling visual.
I precisament d'això es tractava la campanya #totsambelpresident, centrada en la campanya d'Artur Mas en les últimes eleccions catalanes.
Estem poc acostumats a veure un candidat amb una actitud pròxima, humana i fràgil. Està molt bé que es pugui veure un polític que es cansa, que està angoixat, seriós, que té por... Vam posar una persona a l'ombra del president i ens van donar accés a tot arreu. Volíem que el contingut fos exclusiu per a Instagram, i el resultat va ser de molta qualitat. Al final ens va acabar instagramejant ell a nosaltres!

8.7.13

Did Hipster Tech Really Save the Obama Campaign?




Obama’s reelection campaign was like running for Chicago alderman with the help of nerdy kids who spoke a math language no one else understood. The key was microtargeting, which had bad odor in recent years thanks to the marketing industry. Microtargeting sounded intrusive, even a little creepy, but it had the potential to return politics to the most local level of all: the individual voter.

The idea was that everything the geeks did should be a ‘force multiplier’.

From the start, there was trouble in digital paradise — a culture clash. They often took their mandate for ‘disruption’ too far.

Fortunately for Obama, the campaign was loaded with geeks who knew what Facebook could do before Facebook did.

Tech had some terrific people but was so focused on trying — and often failing — to build cool new apps that it didn’t give the teams the workaday tools they wanted.

In truth, Narwhal was always more of a concept than a product.


Obama field organizers, armed with the fruits of Big Data, could bring a presidential campaign to the front porch as never before. OFA’s aim was to use algorithms to enhance the human (and thus more persuasive) part of politics: face-to-face, friend-to-friend, or at least Facebook friend-to-Facebook friend.

The new analysts did something unheard of by profiling and targeting unlikely voters. That transformed registration from a passive activity — sitting at a folding table in a supermarket parking lot — into something active and much more efficient.
By 2011 the technology of the 2008 campaign was long obsolete. So Obama campaign manager Jim Messina set out for the West Coast, where Eric Schmidt, chairman of Google, and executives from Apple, Facebook, Zynga, Microsoft, DreamWorks, and Salesforce all told him he should not just view the campaign as a start-up but hire much of his digital crew from start-ups that were outside of politics. The idea was that everything the geeks did should be a “force multiplier” for Field, Communications, Finance, and other departments, not an end in itself.
The digital team assembled in Chicago was in fact three teams — Digital, Tech, and Analytics — with interrelated and often competitive functions. All were headed by soon-to-be-legendary characters within the campaign. Teddy Goff said he wanted the young recruits in Digital to be so good they could be hired afterward by Nike or Coca-Cola and “not be seen as hippy dippys.” Michael Slaby and Harper Reed hired geeky geniuses from top tech companies ranging from Google to craigslist. Analytics ended up with a motley crew of mostly under-thirty data scientists and financial analysts, plus a biophysicist, a former child prodigy, and three professional poker players.
From the start, there was trouble in digital paradise — a culture clash between the engineers from tech companies and the more politically seasoned product managers and data analysts.
Harper Reed’s code writers, though lacking in campaign experience, were often paid $100,000 a year, twice as much as some of their colleagues in other sections of the campaign. Reed said Tech could afford the higher salaries because it held down head count by hiring fewer people than rival departments. The pay gap was exacerbated by the Tech team’s habit of routinely leaving the office at the ungodly hour of 6:30 p.m., five, six, even seven hours before Digital, Analytics, and other sections went home. This schedule was explained by the fact that they were older (meaning a few were in their mid-thirties) and, unlike most Chicago staffers, often had families.
A little humility would have gone a long way toward helping Tech blend in, but it wasn’t forthcoming. “Instead of ‘Listen and learn,’ they [Tech people] came in with a ‘Burn the place down’ attitude — real arrogant,” said one senior campaign official. “It was, ‘Fuck the vendors — we’ll build everything in-house.’ ” But the vendors, firms like NGP VAN that specialized in voter contact, knew politics, and Reed’s department did not. Tech team members used their fluency in tech jargon to their advantage, but they were often illiterate in basic political language.
And they often took their mandate for “disruption” too far. But all of this would have been minor if the products Tech developed were working.

Facebook vs. The Narwhal Whale

Tech’s great white whale, dubbed “Narwhal” (after a toothed whale), was to integrate the more than 13 million Obama supporters now on the Email List with many other databases.
Instead of modeling and extrapolating, the dream was to match 25 million Facebook “likes” of Obama with county voter registration rolls, census data, 2008 voter contact information, contributor lists, and fresh information from door-to-door canvassers for a unified data platform on millions of voters in battleground states.
In Tech’s defense, the complexity of the Narwhal project was daunting. The hairiest challenge, the goal of Narwhal, was identifying which dieting donor might want to learn more about Michelle Obama’s anti-obesity initiative, or which Obama supporter had once signed a petition for women’s rights and might now be willing to send her whole mailbox something about Mitt Romney’s attack on Planned Parenthood.
This was much harder than it sounded. Some of the people designing Narwhal thought it wouldn’t be fully functional until 2016, by which time Barack Obama, if he won, would be getting ready to leave the White House.
Instead of waiting for Tech to build Narwhal, Analytics compensated by relying more heavily on software from a company called Vertica that helped produce enough new data sets to keep the Cave dwellers happy. And Chris Wegrzyn and Gabriel Burt of Analytics developed a tool dubbed “Stork” that allowed key vendors to transfer their data into campaign databases.
OFA ended up with pieces of Narwhal instead of the whole whale. The best piece of all was Facebook, which was growing so fast that it might be able to accomplish some of what everyone had hoped for from Narwhal.
Fortunately for Obama, the campaign was loaded with geeks who knew what Facebook could do before Facebook did. Rayid Ghani, OFA’s chief data scientist, led a team that began to customize a Facebook app into something called “targeted sharing.” The idea was that if an Obama supporter had, say, one thousand Facebook friends, the campaign could determine that nine hundred of them were already for Obama, focus on one hundred who were persuadable, and ideally zero in on six or so who lived in battleground states and were in regular enough contact to be considered real friends, not just Facebook friends. When those potential Obama voters were identified, their friend (the active Obama supporter) would be notified. He or she could then send them Obama’s position on issues and urge them to register and eventually to vote.
Because the message came from a real friend, it would be much more credible and influential than if it came from a stranger representing the campaign. That was the theory, anyway. All of this was much easier to envision than to execute. Common names meant thousands of cases of mistaken identity. Uncommon names were often misspelled and thus orphaned. Some voters used home addresses, others work addresses.
Digital’s biggest tech innovation was “Quick Donate,” a mobile app that raised an extra $75 million by letting supporters give money with one click instead of filling out a form. Donors who used Quick Donate gave four times as often and three times as much as those who didn’t. The mobile app led to what the campaign called “drunk donating,” where Obama supporters agitated by polls showing Romney gains impulsively kicked in before they thought better of it.
Quick Donate was supposed to be a Tech project, but it was engineered by the less experienced code writers inside Digital. This was another example of why tensions between Tech and the other departments hadn’t eased much. Tech had some terrific people but was so focused on trying — and often failing — to build cool new apps that it didn’t give Digital, Field, Finance, and Comm the workaday tools they wanted.
In June Tech finally came through with Dashboard, which was praised by many field organizers for helping put all of their local efforts at their fingertips. For many Obama volunteers, Dashboard became almost a new social network. It helped tens of thousands tap into the long-delayed Call Tool, which allowed volunteers to join Nurses for Obama, Veterans for Obama, Seniors for Obama, and other subgroups.
Narwhal failed — “a huge disaster,” as one senior staffer put it. A unified data platform, instant access to highly detailed information (beyond support scores) on millions of American voters, would have to wait. It was not yet possible to, say, link a veteran supporting Obama in Ohio to a persuadable veteran from his same army unit in Virginia. Harper Reed’s insistence that Narwhal was a success depended on defining it more narrowly as a “data store” for all of the campaign’s applications.
In truth, Narwhal was always more of a concept than a product. By 2016, maybe even by the 2014 midterms, Democratic geeks might be closer to catching the great toothed whale.
Facebook-targeted sharing, by contrast, was a monster success, especially with the youth vote. In an era in which half of eighteen- to twenty-five-year-olds were unreachable by phone, Facebook was essential for a candidate like Obama.
By the end of the campaign 600,000 Obama supporters had each used Facebook to contact around half a dozen specific friends identified by Chicago: 3.5 million potential Obama voters in battleground states. Nearly one-third of them, one million people, took some action in response, such as registering. This was a staggering response rate and the debut of a digital persuasion and get-out-the-vote tool that would inevitably be adopted by every campaign at every level.
Friend-to-friend was the highest form of voter contact, though it was hardly perfect: A Romney staffer, Matt Lira, was encouraged through targeted sharing to contact his Facebook friend, House Minority Leader Eric Cantor, and urge him to vote for Obama.
Excerpted from The Center Holds.  
Copyright 2013 by Jonathan Alter. Reprinted by permission of Simon & Schuster, Inc. All rights reserved.

24.6.13

La influència de les xarxes

13.06.2013 


El professor i doctorand Marc Perelló, del Departament de Ciències de la Comunicació de la Universitat Abat Oliba CEU de Barcelona, i cap d’opinió de l’IntocableDigital.Cat, ha presentat el seu darrer estudi sobre les xarxes socials i la política catalana a Londres, en el marc del congrés internacional “Protest and the Media” organitzat per la Universitat de Westminster, i que s’ha celebrat els dies 12 i 13 de juny. 

En la seva exposició, Perelló ha exemplificat la força dels nous mitjans amb les massives manifestacions del 10 de juliol de 2010 i de l’11 de setembre del 2012 i la seva relació amb les xarxes socials: “La de l’Estatut està considerada com la primera manifestació 2.0 de la política occidental, i la de la Diada va tenir un abans, durant i després que va fer que és parlés de Catalunya als mitjans internacionals com mai abans”. En aquest sentit, Perelló ha recordat que la manifestació de l’any 2012 va desembocar “en menys de vint dies” en l’anunci d’unes eleccions, un fet que ha qualificat “sense precedents en la democràcia europea recent”, i que “demostra la influencia dels moviments socials coordinats”. També ha afegit que “les protestes físiques estan limitades per l’espai i el temps” però que “les protestes virtuals han acabat amb aquest paradigma. Ara una protesta pot ser infinita”.

Perelló també va destacar la importància de les xarxes en el dia a dia de la política catalana i ha comentat que dels 135 diputats i diputades de Catalunya “el 86% tenen compte a Twitter, el 73% a Facebook, i fins i tot un 36% tenen blog”. Unes xifres en sintonia amb la ciutadania, sobretot tenint en compte que “un 76% dels catalans és connecten a diari a Internet, i un 52% són molt actius les xarxes socials”. En un mapa de llengües fet entre el 2010 i el 2012, s’hi pot veure Catalunya dibuixada gràcies al tuits majoritàriament en català, sent aquesta la 19ª llengua més utilitzada a Twitter (d’un total de 78 estudiades). Perelló també ha volgut destacar la feina de l’equip editorial del 324.cat a través de la creació del Tuitòmetre i les gràfiques que se’n van derivar i que comparaven les temàtiques dels missatges dels polítics, partits i ciutadans en la campanya electoral per a la presidència de la Generalitat del 2012.

En la segona part de l’exposició, Perelló ha adreçat el fenomen de la protesta en una vessant més sociològica i internacional: “La lògica de l’agregació ha existit sempre. La seguda de Greensboro al 1960, l’acampada de Greenham al 1981, i el 15-M de fa dos anys tenen un desenvolupament idèntic”. La diferència cal cercar-la en els nous mitjans: “L’esfera digital és un flux d’informació instantani, constant i sense filtres. En altres paraules: és l’aliat perfecte dels moviments socials contemporanis”. El professor de la UAO CEU també s’ha referit a la Primavera Àrab per afirmar que “Twitter va obrir els ulls al món sencer, però no va ser l’eix de la revolta. Els àrabs estan cansats que es parli de la revolució de Twitter, i tenen raó. Nosaltres comentàvem i difoníem la noticia, però ells eren al carrer enfrontant-se amb els seus governs”. Aquest exemple ha servit a Perelló per concloure que “els moviments de protesta són molt diversos i hi participen molts agents socials. Siguin físics o virtuals, cal estudiar-los amb una òptica transversal, tant teòrica com científicament”.

7.6.13

"En un govern de coalició cal pactar el contingut i la forma d'actuar, i fins i tot els desacords abans que apareguin, perquè apareixeran"



La Consultora Sociopolítica Gironina, Neòpolis, ha elaborat aquests vídeos “Reflexions sobre el món local” amb diferents experts- Quim Brugué, Salvador Cardús, Agustí Bosch, Jesús Badenes, etc- amb la voluntat de reflexionar i produir valor afegit en un moment on l’administració pública local necessita més que mai pensar i innovar per fer front als reptes de futur. Es tracta d’un producte audiovisual composat de 7 capítols de menys de 4 minuts de durada, on diferents experts reflexionen i donen el seu punt de vista sobre les claus de present i de futur dels ens locals del nostre país.
 
En aquest vídeo, el capítol 4, us parlo de com actuar en un govern de coalició però també en un format per un mateix partit polític per prevenir, abordar, gestionar i resoldre els conflictes polítics i públics que es donen, com per exemple, que els governs es dediquen a actuar un cop han guanyat les eleccions en clau electoral, en lloc de govern; o malgrat els pactes es trenquin, perquè pot passar, el cal saber és què fer davant dels desacords i sobretot com actuar; i sobretot per mantenir els pactes i governs de coalició estables s'ha de tenir pocs objectius acordats i que siguin clars, etc.

28.4.13

“Total Noise,” Only Louder. Manhunt

#Manhunt.

  • By James Gleick 
  • Published Apr 20, 2013


  • Kids used to ask each other: If a tree falls in a forest and no one hears, does it make a sound? Now there’s a microphone in every tree and a loudspeaker on every branch, not to mention the video cameras, and we’ve entered the condition that David Foster Wallace called Total Noise: “the tsunami of available fact, context, and perspective.”
    This week was a watershed for Total Noise. When terrible things happen, people naturally reach out for information, which used to mean turning on the television. The rewards (and I use the word in its Pavlovian sense) can be visceral and immediate, if you want to see more bombs explode or towers fall, and plenty of us do. But others are learning not to do that.

    The Boston bombings, shootings, car chase, and manhunt found the ecosystem of information in a strange and unstable state: Twitter on the rise, cable TV in disarray, Internet vigilantes bleeding into the FBI’s staggeringly complex (and triumphant) crash program of forensic video analysis. If there ever was a dividing line between cyberspace and what we used to call the “real world,” it vanished last week.

    Microblogging and social media intruded sharply upon the chain of events. The@CambridgePolice, having tweeted SUSPICIOUS PACKAGE reports through Thursday night and Friday morning, stopped tweeting in case the 19-year-old fugitive Dzhokhar Tsarnaev was glued to his cell phone like everyone else (“monitoring police response via social media”). And why wouldn’t he be? The Internet revealed his supposed Twitter name, which instantly acquired tens of thousands of new followers.
    Reddit users assembled a crowd-sourced map of the Thursday-night shootings and car­jacking. The @Boston_Police begged other tweeters to stop “Broadcasting Tactical Positions of Homes Being Searched.” Someone instantly registered the domain name ­shouldIlivetweetthescanner.info in order to post a short message: “NO. NO, NO and NO.”
    The slain MIT police officer, Sean Collier, was memorialized on an Officer Down Memorial Page. The Chechen president, Ramzan Kadyrov, a.k.a.kadyrov_95, turned to Instagram to announce that, whatever had happened, it was America’s own fault. One of the more popular Twitter hashtags was #surreal. That would have been useful for television news, too, if they had hashtags.

    I managed to evade the television for several days after the bombing. You can get your cable news secondhand, via Twitter or the blogs, which is a little like using a mirror to avoid gazing upon the Gorgon directly. If you did that Wednesday afternoon, you knew something was going on when William Gibson tweeted some weather: “Fog ’o news pea soup solid in Boston right now.” Followed minutes later by the London journalist Charlie Brooker: “CNN is essentially just footage of reporters in the street staring in bewilderment at their iPhones.”

    Fog of News was right. At 1:16 p.m., the reporter John King told the anchor Wolf Blitzer that the police had identified a suspect. “A dark-skinned male,” he said, a bit nervously, “because of the sensitivities some people will take offense even at saying that.” Blitzer said, “We can’t say whether the person spoke with a foreign accent or an American accent or anything like that, that would be premature.”

    At 1:45, Blitzer cut back to King for “more information, exclusive reporting”—namely, that an arrest had been made. “A dramatic, dramatic shift,” King said. Meanwhile, and all along, background video loops: smoke and blood and people running. Carnage recycled as eye candy.

    “I want to be precise, and I want to be sure we have it right,” said Blitzer at 1:51. “It’s important to get this information out there to the American public and important to get this information out there in general, but it’s much more important to make sure that we’re precise and accurate.” King replied: “An arrest has been made. Both Fran [Townsend]’s federal source and my Boston source say an arrest has been made.” None of this, of course, was true. No arrest had been made. No suspect had even been identified. Nor was it “important to get this information out there in general.” There was no information, and no one needed it.

    But when everyone is monitoring everyone else, no one can bear to be left out. Fox News, along with the Associated Press, the Boston Globe, and various local stations, leaped in to report the nonexistent suspect in custody. They all cited unnamed sources and later blamed the sources. The Keystone Koppish retreat lasted about an hour. My favorite bit came on CNN at 2:30, from Fran Townsend, former Homeland Security adviser to George W. Bush and now professional television “contributor”:

    “The situation is very fluid … There was a misunderstanding, I mean, that was said to me, not so much that we have misunderstood but that there has been a misunderstanding and lots of cross-communications and understandably, as law enforcement tries to work through this, what they’ve got, who it is, what the purpose of that is, and what the next steps are. So, I myself have had conflicting reports, and I wanted just to be clear with you that they think that’s a result of the chaos and the quickly unfolding law-enforcement situation up in Boston.”⁠
    Maybe it’s unfair to set down this kind of pressured utterance in print. But cable news generates verbiage in this hollow mode, minute after minute, hour after hour, when people are forced to speak even though they have nothing to say. It’s inherent in the enterprise. In most of what it does, continuous real-time broadcast news is a failed experiment.

    We need to get smarter about the vectors of time and information flow. We know what the hurry is, of course. It is devoutly felt at CNN and Fox News that prestige or viewership or both depend on being the first, even if only by seconds, to announce practically anything. They continue to believe this, even though no one remembers which of them was first to announce erroneously that the Supreme Court had overturned the Affordable Care Act—rushing to botch a fact that had been officially released to the entire infosphere and would soon be universally available to everyone. “We gave our viewers the news as it happened,” Fox said smugly later that day.

    It starts to feel as though we’re Pavlov’s dogs—subjects in a vast experiment in operant conditioning. The craving for information leads to behaviors that are alternately rewarded and punished. If instantaneity is what we want, television cannot compete with cyberspace. Nor does the hive mind wait for officialdom. While the FBI watched and tagged and coded thousands of images from surveillance cameras and cell phones, users on Reddit and 4chan went to work, too, marking up photos with yellow arrows and red circles: “1: ALONE 2: BROWN 3: Black backpack 4: Not watching.”

    Virtually everything these sleuths discovered was wrong. Their best customer was the New York Post, which fronted a giant photo of two “Bag Men”—who, of course, turned out to be a high-school kid and his friend, guilty of nothing but brown skin. If the watchword Wednesday was crowd-source, by Thursday it was witchhunt. Total Noise. But when the FBI’s database of 12 million mug shots offered no help, what could the authorities do but enlist the hive mind in the search?

    Then, if you were really hooked, you joined the manhunt in cyberspace. Reporters tweeted as they ran. ­@Boston_Police tweeted warnings and at least one license plate. 
    Cambridge residents tweeted the sound of sirens, the chatter on the police scanner, and photos of bullet holes. Outsiders tweeted their love of crowd-sourcing and their disdain for the old media.

    “A dozen officer going into our yard …”
    “@msnbc says brothers had bomb, @FoxNews says only a trigger @CNN is clueless …”
    “SWAT is out on Laurel St.…”

    “Boston Police to Twitter: ‘Stop making up fake Twitter accounts, stop tweeting our scanner, stop telling people where we’re going.’ ”

    We’re starting to sense what may happen when everything is seen and everyone is connected. Bits of intelligence amid the din; and new forms of banality. Within hours of his death, the world could examine the videos Tamerlan Tsarnaev watched in his YouTube account and, on his Amazon wish list, some books he wanted.

    http://nymag.com/news/intelligencer/boston-manhunt-2013-4/